BMGT-8028 Week 8 Assignment: Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research Articles

Introduction to Week 8 Assignment

Evaluating research articles is a critical skill for graduate students transitioning from learners to scholars. BMGT-8028 Week 8 Assignment: Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research Articles guide outlines the steps to critique and understand both quantitative and qualitative research articles effectively, enhancing academic prowess and depth of understanding in various research methodologies.

The first step to dissecting and evaluating a research article is the review for clarity and consistency. The abstract, the introduction, the problem statement, and the research hypothesis or research question should be clearly stated and consistent. The reader should be able to understand the relationship between each component. These components set the stage for the rest of the document. Please answer the following questions about elements of the quantitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 1.

Quantitative Research Article Evaluation

Abstract, Introduction, Hypothesis, Research Question, and Literature Review

• Ensure the abstract offers a clear summary and that the introduction adequately sets the context for the research question and hypothesis.
• Evaluate the literature review for its breadth, depth, and relevance to the research question.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the methodology for the quantitative article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 2.

Methodology – Research Design, Methods and Procedures, and Sampling

• Assess the clarity and appropriateness of the research design and methods.
• Consider the sampling strategy’s effectiveness in addressing the research question. 

Example

Please answer the following questions about the quantitative methodology for the quantitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. An extraneous variable can create problems for the researcher. Extraneous variables are undesired variables that can influence the dependent variable and change or invalidate the results of an experiment. Can you identify any extraneous variables in the sample quantitative article?

Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 3.

Quantitative Methodology

• Understand the statistical methods used and their suitability for the research questions posed.
• Examine how variables are defined and measured within the study.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the results presented in the quantitative article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 4.

Analysis, Findings, Discussion

• Discuss how each approach aligns with the respective study’s purpose.
• Analyze the strengths and limitations of each methodological approach in addressing the research questions.

Example

Please answer the following questions about what you observed in the quantitative article regarding research ethics and implications of the research findings. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Summarize your evaluation of this study, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses and proposing possible changes that might improve the study.

Ethics and Implications of the Research Findings

• Scrutinize the ethical considerations reported in the study.
• Consider the broader implications of the research findings within the field.

Example

Please answer the following questions about elements of the qualitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 1.

Qualitative Research Article Evaluation

Abstract, Introduction, Hypothesis, Research Question, and Literature Review

• Check for a comprehensive summary in the abstract and a solid foundation in the introduction.
• Assess the formulation of the research question and the integration of the literature review.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the methodology of the sample qualitative article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of Section 2.

Methodology – Research Design, Methods and Procedures, and Sampling

• Evaluate the appropriateness of the qualitative research design and data collection methods.
• Analyze the process for selecting participants and the depth of the demographic data provided.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the qualitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option.

Information Specific to Qualitative Methodology

• Understand the qualitative methods used and discuss how they contribute to theme development and theory building.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the discussion and analysis elements of the qualitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answers and reflecting on the strengths and weaknesses of the discussion and analysis elements.

Discussion and Analysis

• Assess the depth of the discussion and the logical flow from results to conclusions.
• Evaluate the integrity of the analysis and the justification of the conclusions drawn.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the qualitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Write one paragraph supporting your answer and reflecting on the ethical strengths and weaknesses of the research.

Ethics

• Review ethical considerations, participant consent, and the measures taken to protect participant confidentiality.

Example

Please answer the following questions about the qualitative research article. For questions with Agree/Disagree options, type an “x” in front of your selected option. Summarize your evaluation of this study, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses and proposing possible changes that might improve the study.

Research Contribution to the Literature

• Analyze the contribution of the research to existing knowledge and its implications for future research.

Example

Closing

Mastering the critique of research articles is not just an academic exercise but a foundational skill that enhances a scholar’s ability to engage critically with literature. BMGT-8028 Week 8 Assignment: Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research Articles guide provides a structured approach to dissecting both quantitative and qualitative research, fostering a deeper understanding and application of rigorous academic standards. Use this framework to refine your analytical skills and contribute meaningfully to your field of study. By systematically evaluating each section of both quantitative and qualitative research articles, you develop a critical eye necessary for academic success. This Owlisdom guide should serve as a foundational tool in your educational journey, helping you discern research quality and applicability to your own studies. You can also read BMGT-8028 next module Week 8 Discussion: Critiquing Research: Ethics and Threats to Validity.